Ralph Fahringer wrote on Oct 20
th, 2018 at 9:41am:
Ok... Personally, I would like to read this list of rules. Ed, please know that I do not hold you personally responsible... buuuut... how DO we go about changing these "rules"?
Ask
Right now we are trying to find a solution, taking into account all of your considerations and the gallery & forum software.
We don't want to have people jump through hoops to post a photo but at the same time we have to deal with the current software.
Ron Carrabotta wrote on Oct 20
th, 2018 at 8:44am:
As far as Ben's "Segmented/Basket Illusion", I do a lot of BIs and it is hard to find a large single piece of suitable wood to make BIs. The logical step is to build up a segmented piece and then do the BI. Ben's piece is primarily a Basket Illusion, there is no apparent "segmenting" visible.
A segmented piece, meant to "show off" the segmenting process is a horse of a different color. IMHO.
This is all I was getting at, using the term "segmented" in the description was a bit misleading to me.
This is what I can only guess what started this over reaction IMO
Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!! You need to

or

Walt Nolan wrote
"As a moderator of this board I feel this piece has a few homes it could live in. It was turned so it could go in the Turning forum. It has a special finish applied to it so it could go in the Finishing forum. I am glad that you wisely used segmentation to conserve wood to complete your project. 28 years ago I did the same thing using as cheap a wood I could get to complete my projects.
You response
"I understand why, But- if I was someone new to this site and I wanted to see something a member has posted about "basket illusions" what would I look under. Turning would be my first, maybe finishing section next. Of all the things you mentioned this could be under the very last thing I would look for is segmented turning. Since it does actually "nothing" to do with segmenting other than a way to make the shape.
Just saying I disagree with the decision to put it in segmenting but it's not a big deal and whatever you guys decide I'm with you. "
Walt never told you that you had to put your work anywhere, he actually gave you an option and left it up to you. His only comment about segmenting was that it was a good technique to use.
A giant misunderstanding if you ask me.
Ben, I'm not sure what you are so worked up about.
In response to your posts and other in the past we asked members and started the Embellishment forum. (the system works)
All I did now is post a reminder that finished works should be posted in the gallery.
This has always been the case but not enforced in any way, we simply ask.
As I said, maybe it's time to change some procedures but members need to tell us what they do and don't like or else nothing happens. We are open to reasonable suggestions bu you need to tell us.
What exactly would you like us at WR to do to make your visits better?